Apparently some of the big copyright holders are pushing the government to force Google to completely de-index sites that have been proven to violate DMCA.
I guess it depends on the process they use. And I do not have any faith in the almighty Google’s judgement. Besides have any of the major tube sites / offenders actually been found guilty of violating DMCA?
Potentially it would only take one claim against a site and your entire business is dead.
I don’t think they are pushing a ‘1 notification and then Kaboom’ policy… just for chronic repeat offenders the option of having the whole site removed should provide a better stick to get rid of those who abuse the safe harbor provisions of the DMCA as a ‘get out of jail free’ card